Meredith McIver

Meredith McIver explained that she included the passages from Michelle Obama’s speech after listening to Melania Trump read passages from the 2008 address.
Over the phone, she read me some passages from Mrs. Obama’s speech as examples. I wrote them down and later included some of the phrasing in the draft that ultimately became the final speech. I did not check Mrs. Obama’s speeches. This was my mistake, and I feel terrible for the chaos I have caused Melania and the Trumps, as well as to Mrs. Obama. No harm was meant.

This entry was posted in american way. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Meredith McIver

  1. shinichi says:

    Trump aide offers resignation in Melania Trump plagiarism incident

    by Jeremy Diamond

    http://edition.cnn.com/2016/07/20/politics/trump-aide-offers-resignation-in-melania-trump-plagiarism-incident/

    A speechwriter working for Donald Trump’s company identified herself Wednesday as the person responsible for plagiarism in Melania Trump’s convention speech and offered her resignation.

    Meredith McIver apologized in a statement sent out by the campaign and said Donald and Melania Trump did not accept her resignation.

    “She made a mistake … we all make mistakes,” Donald Trump told ABC News later Wednesday.

    McIver’s statement comes more than 36 hours after reporters uncovered striking similarities between the two speeches –during which time the controversy cast a shadow over Trump’s nominating convention and distracted from coverage of the lineup of speakers.

    McIver explained that she included the passages from Michelle Obama’s speech after listening to Melania Trump read passages from the 2008 address.

    “Over the phone, she read me some passages from Mrs. Obama’s speech as examples. I wrote them down and later included some of the phrasing in the draft that ultimately became the final speech. I did not check Mrs. Obama’s speeches. This was my mistake, and I feel terrible for the chaos I have caused Melania and the Trumps, as well as to Mrs. Obama. No harm was meant.”

    Donald Trump also cited McIvers by name in a 2007 deposition for a civil lawsuit for errors in his books. That deposition was first reported by the Washington Post.

    She said Wednesday the Trump family rejected her resignation, because, “Mr. Trump told me that people make innocent mistakes and that we learn and grow from these experiences.”

    McIver said she “asked” to put out a statement because she was concerned about how the controversy was “distracting from Mr. Trump’s historic campaign for president and Melania’s beautiful message and presentation.”

    “I apologize for the confusion and hysteria my mistake has caused. Today, more than ever, I am honored to work for such a great family,” McIver said in the statement.

    The Trump campaign has refused to acknowledge the incident as plagiarism, instead slamming the media and insisting it was moving on, with no plans to fire any staffers.

    But a source close to the Trump campaign conceded that the flap could be a problem for the Republican nominee’s campaign. The source specifically focused on McIver’s statement, written on Trump Organization letterhead. The source characterized that decision as a big mistake.

    That kind of arrangement could raise questions about why someone working for Trump’s company was also performing a role for the campaign.

    Senior members of Trump’s campaign continued to herald Melania Trump’s speech.

    “The speech was very effective and communicated those feelings,” Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort said Tuesday on CNN’s “New Day.” “The controversy you’re talking about is not meaningful at all. She’s not a candidate for office. She was expressing her personal feelings about her country and her husband and why he’s best for the United States.”

    Manafort on Wednesday agreed Melania Trump’s speech used “similar words” to Obama’s and insisted, “I’m not lying about anything.”

    The Republican National Committee also boosted the Trump campaign’s defense, with its communications director Sean Spicer slapping down plagiarism charges by pointing to similar words and themes in everything from John Legend songs to “My Little Pony.”

    John Kasich turned down ‘most powerful’ VP slot from Trump

    Donald Trump, for his part, pressed forward with the strategy of attacking the media as late as an hour before the campaign statement Wednesday.

    “The media is spending more time doing a forensic analysis of Melania’s speech than the FBI spent on Hillary’s emails,” Trump said in a tweet.

    McIver has served as a ghostwriter for the Trumps in the past, helping Donald Trump write some of his books, including “Trump: Think Like a Billionaire.”

    The New York Times identified McIver as a former ballet dancer and English major.

  2. shinichi says:

    トランプ氏夫人演説
    スピーチライターが盗用認め謝罪

    by 西田進一郎

    http://mainichi.jp/articles/20160721/k00/00e/030/207000c

     米共和党大統領候補である実業家ドナルド・トランプ氏(70)の夫人メラニアさん(46)が党全国大会で行った演説の盗用疑惑で、トランプ氏陣営は20日、スピーチライターのメレディス・マクアイバー氏が盗用したことを認め、謝罪する声明を出した。マクアイバー氏は辞任を申し出たが、トランプ氏が慰留したという。

     メラニアさんは大会初日の18日に演説した。しかし、一部に8年前の民主党全国大会でミシェル・オバマ大統領夫人が行った演説と酷似する言葉があり、盗用ではないかとの声が上がっていた。

     声明によると、マクアイバー氏がメラニアさんと演説内容について電話でやりとりした際、ミシェル夫人のことが好きなメラニアさんが、国民に伝えたいことの一例として、ミシェル夫人の過去の演説の一節を読み上げた。これを書き留めたマクアイバー氏は、いくつかを演説の草稿に入れ、最後までそれらが残ったという。

     マクアイバー氏はミシェル夫人の演説を直接確認しなかったとし「私のミスであり、悪意はなかった」と説明した。

     マクアイバー氏は19日にトランプ氏に辞任を申し出たが「誰でも悪意のない間違いはするし、その経験から学んで成長するものだ」と慰留されたという。

  3. shinichi says:

    (sk)

    スピーチライターがスピーチを書いていることは、もはや常識になっている。

    「本人とスピーチライターとの打ち合わせで誤解が生じ、それが間違いにつながった」という言い訳は、とても上手かった。

    時間がかかったとはいえ、上手にケースをクローズしたのは、さすがとしか言えない。

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.